M4 Mac mini – is it really THAT good?

Possibly the best Mac – ever! The buzz surrounding the Mac mini M4 is insane right now. I can’t remember this much buzz or excitement around

David Lewis
November 15, 2024

Possibly the best Mac – ever!

M4 Mac mini

The buzz surrounding the Mac mini M4 is insane right now.

I can’t remember this much buzz or excitement around an Apple device in a very long time. Possibly the first Apple silicon Macs caused these kinds of emotions – but one thing is for certain – Apple has nailed it with the Mac mini.

I had an inkling that they might be on to something special with M4 silicon so it only took me a couple of days to get my order in. It looked to be so special that I began to think that this M4 Mac mini may even be able to replace my 3-year-old workhorse – the mighty M1 Max MacBook Pro.

That Mac was my first taste of Apple silicon – I was coming from a 2015 Intel iMac and it was quite a baptism! That Mac was and still is brilliant. When I think of the work I’ve done on it over the years and barely does it ever complain!

But…the word is this M4 Apple silicon is a pretty special step forward. To give you an idea of the spec comparison, the M1 Max has 32GB of unified memory and importantly two media decoding engines which could prove to be the decisive factor in my keeping that MacBook as my daily machine.

I decided to tick most of the option boxes on the M4 Mac mini Pro to give it a chance to shine:

  • 1TB SSD storage
  • 48GB unified memory
  • M4 Pro chip with the 14-core CPU and 20-core GPU upgrade
  • 10GB Ethernet port

With these specs, I’d be in a great place to see if a ‘downgrade’ from a Max to a Pro chip would be a fair battle. My gut feeling was that the three years separating them would make a difference.

Things move on right?

The only problem with my customer order mini was that it was going to take time to arrive – so while I was waiting, guess what? I went and bought another one – this one was an off-the-shelf unit.

I needed to check out the Mac mini for myself and see what the fuss was about and I didn’t want to wait.

M4 Mac mini – getting it right

I’ve never been the sort to run Geekbench tests – it’s never been my thing, so I decided to set this new Mac mini up with the kind of creative programs that I would generally use on my Macs.

I know I’m no coder, 3D render artist or gamer, but I still think I put my Macs through a pretty hard day. The programs I loaded up were Final Cut Pro, Photoshop, Lightroom and Audition.

In Lightroom, I opened up about 20 or 30 photos and applied some pretty chunky presets to them. The bulk export time was lightning fast and every bit the match of my MacBook. If there was any difference in speed it was minimal.

In Photoshop I opened up a complex multi-layered template and again it was flying – no beachballing, stuttering, thinking or delays. So far the signs were bloody impressive.

Pushing it

The two apps that would surely begin to push the middle-range M4 Mac mini (this one has 24GB of memory and 512GB of SSD storage) would be Audition and Final Cut.

I’d kept the file from my recent podcast which would be what I’d use in this test. The file is an hour long so it’s a reasonable test. Bouncing the audio file out was a massive surprise. The little Mac mini was quicker by 5 seconds which was a bit of an eye-opener.

On to the video test – admittedly it wasn’t a complicated file with a ton of plugins and multi-layered but it was an hour-long 1080p video so I figured it to be a fair enough test to run.

The M1 Max would surely win this test, right?

Well, it did – but not by much. The M1 Max MacBook cost over £3500 when I bought it compared to £1000 for the M4 Mac mini – and the difference in export times was just a touch over a minute. The MacBook did it in around 5mins 14 and the Mac mini in 6mins 31.

And don’t forget – this is not even the Mac mini Pro – this is the bog standard off-the-shelf Mac. If this model was performing this well then I couldn’t wait to get my hands on that well spec’d mini of mine that is on the way.

Bear in mind that all of this testing was done with about 30 tabs open in Chrome. Needless to say, I didn’t once hear a fan and it barely even got warm. I ran that Mac mini for about 8 hours that day and it just sat there quietly doing its sweet thing.

A bargain

This Mac doubles up too – you are almost getting two-for-one with this Mac mini.

Where I’d heard that some of the earlier minis had issues with hooking up to TVs this one was plug-and-play – no issues at all. That means that this Mac mini is almost my go-to portable rig now.

It’s smaller and lighter than my MacBook Pro, MacBook Air or 13-inch M4 iPad. All I need to take is the Mac mini (which is tiny), a keyboard and mouse and I’m done!

Although I don’t have another Studio Display at home – my monitor of choice – I can use the 55-inch TV instead which isn’t a bad workaround!

The Mac mini has caused a stir with good reason. In my first week of using it, I’ve not a single bad word to say about it.

Actually, strike that…there is one small problem…a mini problem if you will!

The one missing thing…

The Mac mini has an impressive array of I/O.

On the front, there are two USB-C ports with support for USB 3 and also a headphone jack.

On the back things are equally as impressive – with the M4 Mac mini having three Thunderbolt 4 (USB-C) ports with the M4 Pro swapping those out for three Thunderbolt 5 (USB-C) ports. There is also a full-size HDMI port and an Ethernet port which is configurable up to 10GB (true to its server heritage).

I’ll come back to the Thunderbolt 5 ports in just a second, but the one glaring omission is an SD card slot. Damn – I miss that. Although I swear by my Ivanky FusionDock Max 1 the more built-in I/O the better as far as I’m concerned. I know if Apple had included an SD card slot it would have moved it one stage closer to the Mac Studio, but still, we can dream.

Back to Thunderbolt 5 and time to clear up some confusion that’s arisen since it was first mentioned.

Thunderbolt 5 will double the standard data transfer speed to 80 Gbps in both directions, by using some kind of bandwidth boost mode which will reach up to 120 Gbps for video-intensive tasks.

In plain English, that means that the 120Gbps that Apple touted is restricted to display data. Data transfer is much quicker than before too, just not the 120Gbps headline we first saw.

Another benefit is that the maximum power delivery also gets a meaningful boost. Thunderbolt 5 will deliver 240W charging up from the 100W limit available from Thunderbolt 4. So, if you are looking for a quick way to charge up those juicy M4 MacBook Pros – here’s your answer. Just make sure you have the correct Thunderbolt 5 cable though if want to take advantage of this.

One more thing

Yesterday my M4 Pro Mac mini arrived and after finishing writing this my next job is going to be unboxing it and working out ways of comparing it to not only the other Mac mini but also the M1 Max MacBook Pro, 15-inch M3 MacBook Air and M3 iMac.

The buzz surrounding these new Macs is undeniable – and Apple has been ever so clever in what they’ve done. The execs at Apple are well aware that due to the runaway success of Apple silicon, fewer and fewer new Macs are going to be sold purely on the premise of performance. All Apple silicon Macs are fast.

What they have done with the Mac mini is redesigned it and made the hardware the latest, sexy must-have thing. My guess is this is a recipe we can expect to see trotted out a bit more regularly over the next few years.

A few years ago I wrote that we’d never experience the quantum leap forward that we saw from Intel to Apple silicon. I said then it was a once-in-a-generation thing.

It seems I was wrong. The M4 Mac mini has proven so popular that when I was in London last weekend to pick up a base 16GB/256GB/£599 mini – none were to be had. Those were clean out of stock for up to a week! Proof if any was needed that these Macs are ridiculously popular!

With the M4 chip and the M4 Mac mini in particular, Apple has raised the bar yet again!

Are you subscribed to Medium yet?

I am only one of a whole host of writers here on Medium, the premium blogging site. It is such good value, and you can join below.

Share this article

Latest Posts

About the author

Picture of David Lewis

David Lewis

YouTuber, podcaster and blogger, covering everything you’ll ever need to know about Apple.

Latest Podcasts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay in the Loop - for Free!

Get the latest Apple news, reviews, and podcast episodes straight to your inbox. No fuss, no cost, just the good stuff.